1

For example

この中でどれが一番難しいのですか。

数学が一番難しいのです

Is the の here used as nominalizer meaning "one" or is it used as explanatory/emphasizing のです?

I assume the sentences translate to "Amongst these (courses) which is the most difficult one? Math is the most difficult one."

Therefore I think the の here is a nominalizer, but I rememberer reading that nominalizing の cannot be used before です and we should use こと instead. For example:

私の趣味は映画を見るのです。x

私の趣味は映画を見ることです。√

Community
  • 1
Misaka
  • 487
  • 1
  • 4
  • 8

1 Answers1

2

Usage of の devides into (1) pronoun and (2) nominalizer.

  1. 難しいのと簡単なやつ、どっちがいい？ Which do you like, difficult one and easy one?
  2. それが難しいのは知っている I know that it's difficult.

And, when the nominalizer appears in the position of the predecate of the sentence, we call it "explanatory/emphasizing の".

Speaking of your examples, you can regard この中でどれが一番難しいのですか and 数学が一番難しいのです as either pronoun or explanatory の.

As you say, you can't use nominalizer の in the position of the predecate unless it's explanatory/emphasizing の. In other words, の can be used before です when it's a pronoun or explanatory/emphasizing の.

  • そのメガネは映画を見るのです Those glasses are one to watch movies
  • 何するんですか？ → 映画を見るんです
user4092
  • 16,574
  • 20
  • 23